In its September 2025 report entitled Planning and Acquiring Nursing Home Beds, the Auditor General of Nova Scotia found that the Department of Seniors and Long-term Care used an improper “right of first refusal” process to favour existing long term care providers in the award of contracts for the construction of new long-term care facilities. The report concluded that the process did not comply with provincial procurement legislation.
As the Auditor General noted, the Department “indicated it used the right-of-first-refusal process to maintain the already stable relationship with existing service providers and to avoid economic costs – such as laying off staff, finding temporary accommodation for residents, and setting up new operations.” However, the report found that “management could not provide evidence that economic impact studies were completed to show this approach provided the best value to Nova Scotians.”
The Auditor General determined that the provincial Public Procurement Act did not recognize the use of a right-of-first-refusal process and that “this approach is not appropriate as it does not follow the government’s established procedures to obtain value for money.” The Auditor General concluded that the Department should follow open procurement rules for the construction of new facilities for long term care beds.
This case study, which underscores the importance of establishing formal protocols requiring compliance with open competition rules, will be featured in the Complying with Open Competition duties module of our new Fundamentals of Canadian Government Procurement certificate program that runs in April and returns in October. Please see our current training schedule for more details.