By Paul Emanuelli

This article is an excerpt from The Art of Tendering: A Global Due Diligence Guide, which is available for purchase.

While it may be tempting to dismiss recent high-profile procurement failures as random, isolated incidents, the sad reality is that the steady flow of negative newsreel reports, adverse audit findings, and costly legal entanglements are nothing more than early warning tremors, symptomatic of deeper tectonic tensions grinding away within the depths of many public procurement operations. With major project meltdowns quickly becoming the new normal, this discussion will recommend a three-point crisis-control plan for senior-level governments, individual institutions, and project teams that want to build winning conditions for their procurement projects.

Evolving a Statutory Spine

In many ways, public institutions within Canada face some of the most pressing governance challenges. After creating open competition duties under various trade treaties, most senior-level governments in Canada have failed to establish clear and uniform operating systems to help public institutions run their major procurement projects. In contrast to the statutory procurement frameworks in place at the national and local levels in the United Kingdom, across Europe, in the United States, and in most other Commonwealth jurisdictions, Canada, and to a smaller extent New Zealand, is an outlier, lacking the statutory spine of uniform operating procedures. Thousands of Canadian institutions are currently fending for themselves, operating on the fringes of frontier-style procurement, with a patchwork of do-it-yourself local systems full of duplication, inefficiency, and unnecessary complexity. For the most part, these local systems lack proper internal governance frameworks or adequate dispute resolution procedures. In fact, given recent international trade treaty developments, most Canadian public institutions, particularly at sub-federal levels, have little experience navigating the headwinds of full treaty compliance in the highly regulated and litigious environment of international bid disputes. Many would be in for a rude awakening if they tested the waters of treaty compliance on a major project based on their current practices. Given the new Canada-European Union trade treaty, this is a recipe for disaster. Before implementing the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), senior-level governments should have, at minimum, first ensured that they had the proper statutory and administrative operating systems in place to deal with the bid disputes that will inevitably become the new normal. Leaving the system open-ended leaves Canadian institutions vulnerable to the unpredictability of common law judicial review challenges. While Canada may be an extreme example of this vulnerability, all public institutions that operate in rule-of-law jurisdictions face similar risks if their internal governance practices fail to align with common core global standards.

Building Local Governance Frameworks Globally

Turning beyond Canada, the presence of a statutory spine at the jurisdictional level does not reduce the importance of implementing a proper procurement governance framework at the local level. At the institutional level, this calls for the creation of senior-level budget approval protocols tied to advanced planning and clear delegations to project teams at the very beginning of a project. Those approvals should be based on a project design plan with clear contract scoping and pricing and award criteria, along with clearly defined project roles and responsibilities. Yet, as evidenced by project failures that are global in scale and epic in proportion, many public institutions worldwide have clearly failed to establish clear local governance frameworks for dealing with major projects. Instead, they improvise based on ill-fitting routine procurement procedures. This improvisation leads to indecision, delay, under resourcing, poor planning, and failures in project execution. Building a proactive local governance framework should be the top priority for all public institutions that want to reduce the risk of major project meltdowns.

Deploying Flexible Formats

If project teams want to increase their success rates, they need to use updated tendering procedures that are properly aligned with international standards and the demands of complex projects. Many Commonwealth institutions remain trapped in a tendering time warp, using inflexible Contract A formats embedded with antiquated high-risk process rules that have not been updated in decades and that needlessly subject the institution to lost-profit claims by losing bidders. By contrast, the US has gone through two rounds of reforms led by the American Bar Association. The American Bar Association Model Procurement Code sets uniform statutory standards for bidding procedures across state and local governments, which have been  adopted throughout the US and have resulted in greater standardization and far less litigation when compared to Canada.

The United Nations has followed a similar path, with the United Nations Commission on International Trade Model Procurement Law.  Procedures based on the UN rules have been adopted by a multitude of countries, including the UK and Europe. These statutory codes have long recognized the use of flexible negotiated Request for Proposals formats for major procurement projects and have also recognized, and even mandated, the use of electronic bidding to promote supplier competition across borders. Deploying electronic tendering platforms and flexible tendering formats tailored to local legal requirements give procurement teams in all jurisdictions the necessary tools to succeed with their major projects.

Increasing the Odds of Success

Trying to succeed in major projects while locked in a system that lacks clear statutory rules, solid local governance frameworks, and updated tendering procedures is a high-risk approach that has repeatedly been proven to fail. The public interest demands that we improve those odds for our project teams if we want to avoid even more major project meltdowns in the years to come.