In its July 2025 determination in West Coast Wildlife Control Services Ltd. v. Department of Public Works and Government Services, the Canadian International Trade Tribunal rejected the complainant’s claim that the government awarded a contract to a non-compliant competing bidder. The dispute dealt with a request for standing offer (RFSO) for wildlife control services at Canadian Forces Base Comox in British Columbia. The RFSO required bidders to propose a senior employee with five years of consecutive experience for the relevant services at an airfield of a similar size and scope to where the services were required.
The complainant alleged that the employee proposed by the winning bidder did not have the required experience since the RFSO required that each year’s experience had to be obtained at the same airfield to qualify as a year’s experience, but the proposed employee was unable to show that each year’s experience was for a 12-month period at the same location. The Tribunal disagreed with that restrictive interpretation, finding that each year’s experience could be gained by working at more than one location since the requirement called for experience at “an airfield” rather than stating “at one airfield”, “at the same airfield”, or “at a single airfield”. Based on these interpretive subtleties, the Tribunal concluded that the winning bidder’s experience complied with the mandatory technical requirement.
While this bid protest was ultimately rejected, this case serves as another example of the inherent risks associated with scoring prior experience, particularly when that factor is scored on a pass-fail mandatory requirement basis. Since the evaluation of prior experience is inherently prone to interpretive disputes, purchasing institutions should avoid evaluating that factor on an all-or-nothing pass-fail basis as a mandatory requirement and should instead assess that criterion as a scored category, with potentially a minimum scoring threshold, to reduce the risk of exposing the award decision to bid compliance challenges.
The themes in this article will be explored in greater detail in the new RFx Drafting in the Canadian Public Sector certificate program that runs in May and repeats again in November. Please see our current training schedule for more details.