By Paul Emanuelli

The foundations of our public procurement system are crumbling. Long-term neglect, coupled with a lack of coherent strategic direction, is resulting in chronic structural failures at all levels of government in every region in Canada. If they hope to reverse course, public institutions need to focus on the fundamentals of good governance and prioritize the restoration of their procurement operations.

While government institutions continue to politicize public procurement with preferential practices that violate long-standing non-discrimination rules, and with “cost saving” schemes that lead to centralized gridlock but never seem to save any money, the public procurement system is chronically under-prioritized, under-resourced, under-staffed, under-trained, and under-performing.

Many public institutions, who struggle to keep the lights on and source the goods and services that are critical to delivering essential services to the public, chronically short-change the system that lies at the heart of their operations while imposing arbitrary, contradictory, and onerous new burdens onto that system. The deadly combination of long-term neglect and short-sighted expedience has led to misplaced priorities and a lack of strategic direction, which has inevitably resulted in widespread systemic failures.

The evidence on point is irrefutable. The latest case studies confirm what was proven years ago. The failures speak for themselves. They are both systemic and chronic. They are systemic because they are caused by long-standing structural defects in the institutional governance of public institutions. They are chronic because the systemic defects are well known across the public sector, but many public institutions keep making the same mistakes year after year with no course corrections.

The symptoms of systemic failure are everywhere. We see the signs in repeated reports and rulings that call for more procurement training to improve system-wide compliance and efficiency while many public institutions cut their training budgets for short-sighted savings and then wonder why billions in government spending are chronically mismanaged.

We see the signs in the recurring failure to implement recommendations flowing out of public inquiries and public audit reports, and in the slow and steady erosion of regulatory oversight at federal and provincial levels.

We see the signs in the ongoing failure to adopt ethical standards that promote a culture of compliance, and in the recurring circumvention of open tendering rules through sole-sourcing loopholes, contract splitting schemes, and non-transparent invitational tendering processes. We see the signs in the speed with which many public institutions concoct new ways to circumvent the procurement rules while having no apparent sense of urgency when it comes to maintaining public infrastructure and reducing wasteful spending.

We see the signs in chronic conflict and collusion controversies including political interference, improper lobbying, influence peddling, bid-rigging, bribery, insider advantage and biased contract awards.

We see the signs in recurring major project failures, caused by the same structural defects in project governance, that year after year lead to the same delivery delays and cost overruns. We see the signs in the inability to manage the basic mechanics of a bidding system, where public institutions regularly fail to meet minimum tendering timelines, follow transparent procedures, define clear mandatory bid requirements, disclose transparent evaluation criteria, or maintain proper records to defend their award decisions. We see the signs in the repeated failure to meet minimum contract administration standards, including the failure to review invoices and confirm that work was performed before payments are made.

Finally, and most fundamentally, we see the signs of chronic systemic failure in the perpetual vacuum in leadership, where senior governments are more likely to serve as the source of new procurement problems then they are to deliver any meaningful solutions for the broader public sector, and in the long-standing failure to replace stagnant organizational cultures that are mired in inertia, risk avoidance and red tape with dynamic operating systems that reward improvement and innovation.

The signs are as clear as the consequences are stark. For example, in this past year alone, we saw how procurement failures led to billions in cost overruns in military and technology procurements and billions in waste in our health sector. We saw how procurement failures led to major extra charges in a highway expansion project, delays in launching new public transit systems, delays in repairing existing university facilities, delays in maintaining municipal sewer infrastructure, and longer wait times in a strained public housing system.

When procurement stops working government stops functioning. Given the consequences of failure, it is now a matter of national importance that Canadian public institutions forge a path forward by implementing long overdue reforms to their procurement operations.

The themes in this article will be explored in greater detail in our new Fundamentals of Canadian Government Procurement certificate program that runs in April and returns in October. Please see our current training schedule for more details.