Public institutions are subject to treaty-mandated debriefing rules which, based on existing case law, puts those institutions under a duty to provide information to losing bidders to explain why they did not win a bidding process, while at the same time protecting the confidential information submitted by competing bidders. In addition to striking the right balance between transparency and confidentiality, the case law also recognizes that purchasing institutions are under a duty to ensure that losing bidders understand their bid protest rights. The following recent cases illustrate how compliance with these duties remains subject to legal challenge.
For example, in its October 2024 determination in C-CORE v. Department of Natural Resources, the Canadian International Trade Tribunal criticized the government’s failure to advise a losing bidder of its bid protest rights during the debriefing process.
The dispute dealt with an RFP for geospatial web harvester development and operations services. The Tribunal ruled that the complainant was properly rejected as non-compliant for failing to demonstrate the required experience. After being notified of the evaluation result, the complainant informed the government that it would be seeking recourse with the Office of the Procurement Ombud (OPO). The government remained silent and failed to inform the complainant that the OPO did not have jurisdiction over the procurement and that the Canadian International Trade Tribunal had jurisdiction to hear any bid protest arising out of that bidding process.
The Tribunal raised concerns over the government’s failure to properly notify the complainant of its bid protest rights, stating that the recurring situations of government institutions failing to inform bidders of their rights was “extremely regrettable”. As the Tribunal cautioned, “government institutions are committing a disservice to the integrity of the competitive procurement system and frustrating access to justice by omission whenever they fail to correct a potential supplier’s misconception that it has recourse to OPO when it ought to be going to the Tribunal.”
More specifically, the Tribunal noted that by staying silent on bid protest rights or failing to clarify bidder confusion over whether to bring complaints to the OPO or to the Tribunal “government institutions may prejudice (and abridge) the time frame within which a potential supplier must file a complaint with the Tribunal, and therefore increase the risk that an otherwise legitimate complainant may be filed beyond the time frames.” The Tribunal also stated that “when a government institution lets a supplier go to OPO when the government institution knows that OPO does not have jurisdiction, the government institution becomes complicit in allowing the potential supplier to waste precious time in the 10 working-day deadline within which the potential supplier must file a complaint with the Tribunal.”
Moving forward, the Tribunal stated that government institutions “should be accurately informing potential suppliers of available recourse mechanisms to ensure that complaints are directed to the right organization” since government institutions “have a duty to uphold Parliament’s intent to have a properly functioning bid challenge system.” As this case illustrates, public institutions should update their procurement practices to ensure that bidders are properly informed of their bid protest rights.
When administering a debriefing process, public institutions must strike a fine balance between disclosing information to losing bidders and protecting the confidential information submitted by other bidders. For example, in its January 2026 determination in Formation New Era & Martin Robichaud EduCo Services Inc. in Joint Venture v. Department of Employment and Social Development, the Canadian International Trade Tribunal found that the government failed to properly disclose how it scored a losing bidder’s financial proposal. The dispute dealt with a solicitation for virtual training services for call centre employees. The complainant challenged the government’s refusal to disclose how pricing for the extension options factored into the overall scoring of its price.
The Tribunal determined that the government should have disclosed the scoring method it used to score the extension options as part of its overall price evaluation and that it should have provided the losing bidder with its specific price scores during the debriefing process. However, the Tribunal also ruled that the pricing information should have been disclosed in a redacted format to protect the confidential pricing information of the other bidders. As this case illustrates, while public institutions should disclose the method they use to scoring pricing, they should avoid disclosing confidential bidder pricing information to competing bidders during a debriefing process.
While balancing transparency and confidentiality may be a complex exercise, the method of communicating information to losing bidders does not need to be an onerous process. In fact, in some circumstances debriefing duties can be satisfied through written communications without requiring a live debriefing. For example, in its October 2024 determination in TYR Tactical Canada ULC v. Department of Public Works and Government Services, the Canadian International Trade Tribunal found that the government’s written process satisfied the debriefing requirements notwithstanding the complainant’s assertion that it should have been provided a live debrief.
The dispute dealt with a debriefing provided at the conclusion of a solicitation for light infantry equipment for the Department of National Defence. While a losing bidder took issue with the government’s written debriefing process, the Tribunal found that a live debriefing was not required in that case since sufficient information was provided by email to explain why that bidder did not win the contract. As the Tribunal noted, “the Tribunal is of the view that an in-person or telephone debrief is not required to meet the requirement of Article 516(1) of the CFTA” since that provision “does not specify a form that a procuring entity must use to provide an unsuccessful supplier with an explanation of the reasons why the procuring entity did not select its tender”.
In fact, the Tribunal found that the government’s email communication “constituted a valid format” for providing the bidder with the necessary information to satisfy the debriefing duty. As this case illustrates, in certain circumstances, government institutions may be able to satisfy their debriefing duties through written processes without requiring live meetings with losing bidders.
As these recent cases illustrates, public institutions should update their debriefing protocols and procedures to better ensure compliance with evolving case law developments.
The themes in this article will be explored in greater detail in the Navigating Debriefing Disclosures and Confidentiality Duties module of our new Fundamentals of Canadian Government Procurement certificate program that runs in April and returns in October. Please see our current training schedule for more details.