By Paul Emanuelli

In its March 2025 determination in White Bear Industries Ltd. v. Department of Public Works and Government Services, the Canadian International Trade Tribunal found that the government improperly rejected an incumbent bidder over a change order dispute arising out of a prior contract and awarded that bidder lost profits for the improper bid rejection. The dispute dealt with an RFP for highway maintenance services on a portion of the Alaska Highway in British Columbia. Citing a provision in the RFP that allowed for the rejection of bids due to prior performance issues, the government rejected the complainant’s bid. The complainant, White Bear Industries Ltd. (WBI) brought a bid protest challenging that decision.

As the Tribunal noted, the RFP rules set strict parameters around rejecting bids due to prior conduct. Those rules called for evidence of one of the following to justify a bid rejection: (i) fraud; (ii) bribery; (iii) fraudulent misrepresentation; (iv) the failure to comply with any law protecting individuals from any manner of discrimination; or (vi) improperly performed work or unsuitable conduct.

The Tribunal ruled that the government was unable to provide evidence to justify rejecting the complainant’s bid on any of these grounds. While the government relied on a change order dispute arising out of a prior contract as the primary reason for rejecting the complainant’s bid, the Tribunal noted that the contract dispute remained unresolved between the parties. The Tribunal also noted that the government’s representatives had initially approved the contract adjustments that were now under dispute. Further, the Tribunal noted that it did not have the jurisdiction to adjudicate the change order dispute since its mandate is restricted to bid protests rather than post-award contract disputes.

While the RFP rules allowed for the rejection of bids due to prior performance issues, the Tribunal noted that “this does not mean that a decision to reject a bid can be made with unlimited discretion or untethered to any evidential standard.” The Tribunal concluded that the government failed to provide evidence to justify the rejection over the change order dispute since the government was “second-guessing, with hindsight, the discretion exercised by its employees” who had initially directed the complainant to “acquire or supply additional materials to perform the contract.”

Further, the Tribunal noted that there was “no evidence before the Tribunal to suggest that this discretion was wrongly or unreasonably exercised” by the government employees who initially authorized the retroactively disputed change orders. After noting that the change order dispute amounted to less than one percent of the value of the contract (with the amounts under dispute being $780,000 on a contract valued at approximately $80 million) the Tribunal found that there was no evidence that the government considered the proportionality of the dispute before deciding to reject the bid. As the Tribunal stated, the “underlying necessity of the equipment and materials requisitioned by the Disputed Agreements and the proportionality of their cost, relative to the overall contract value, are relevant factors and vital information that should have been gathered and considered during bid evaluation, but were not.”

Further, the Tribunal noted that the government could not rely on its own failure to properly manage its change order process as a reason to disqualify the complainant’s bid. As the Tribunal stated, the government’s “non-conformity with established internal procedures does not reasonably lead to the conclusion that WBI was responsible for those issues or was deceitful or attempting to perpetuate fraud.” After rejecting the grounds of fraud as a valid basis for rejecting the bid, the Tribunal also concluded that the change order dispute did not justify a bid rejection on any other grounds stated in the RFP. The Tribunal therefore awarded the complainant its lost profits as a remedy for the improper disqualification of its bid.

As this case illustrates, government institutions should exercise a high degree of diligence before relying on prior contract disputes as a basis for rejecting a bid, particularly when the matters under dispute remained unresolved and the government’s contract management practices failed to follow their own established procedures.

The themes in this article will be explored in greater detail in the Managing Supplier Performance and Debarment module of our new Fundamentals of Canadian Government Procurement certificate program that runs in April and returns in October. Please see our current training schedule for more details.