By: Paul Emanuelli
This article is an excerpt from the 2021 edition of The Art of Tendering: A Global Due Diligence Guide, which is available for purchase.
This briefing provides some guidelines on how to manage ongoing procurement operations, while also planning procurements that are financed through stimulus spending during the global pandemic.
Serving the Public Interest
In addition to serving as a key method of delivering essential goods and services to the public by securing critical supply chains, government procurement also serves as a major driver of economic activity. In fact, each year public institutions flow billions into local economies through the award of government contracts.
Given this dual role as a critical channel for public service delivery, as well as a major driver of economic activity, it is a matter of paramount public interest that government procurement be managed with a high degree of speed and precision, especially in crisis situations.
An Economic Engine
While some public institutions may be tempted to shut down all non-critical aspects of their ongoing operations in response to a major emergency such as a global pandemic, that approach to business continuity will actually make the situation worse by triggering avoidable economic downturns.
To put this challenge in context, government procurement accounts for 12 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) across Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries and there is a strong correlation between higher levels of government procurement expenditures and higher living standards. For example, the OECD reports that government procurement ranges from as low as 5.1 percent of GDP in Mexico to as high as 20.2 percent of GDP in the Netherlands. When the engines of government procurement fail, this has a stalling effect on the economy and an adverse impact on our living standards.
While public institutions should ensure that their staff are safe through social distancing and that their emergency operations are prioritized, they should avoid overreacting by unnecessarily shutting down other business operations that can be performed remotely.
Leaving staff idle and ignoring general procurement operations will only prolong the impact of the global pandemic by causing serious economic disruption. Many suppliers, especially in industries that can continue to provide services remotely, are facing significant reductions in their business and would welcome ongoing business opportunities to maintain their own operations and avoid staff layoffs.
Public institutions should therefore revert to a virtual version of “business as usual” as soon as possible and, to the greatest extent possible, should prioritize all procurements that can be delivered remotely to minimize impacts to their business operations and to the overall economy.
The following guidelines should help public sector decision-makers in dealing with the current pandemic.
General Procurement Rules Still Apply
Unless the specific procurement falls within a legitimate emergency exception or another direct award exception, general procurement operations, as well as procurements funded by stimulus spending, should be conducted in accordance with open tendering protocols.
Implementing Fast-Tracked Tendering
For those areas that do not fall within the emergency exception or other direct award exceptions, purchasing institutions should implement a fast-tracked approach to planning and executing their procurements by focusing on clear scoping and pricing structures, transparent evaluation criteria, and properly tailored strategies for accelerating their tendering procedures and contract award processes.
The Risk of Rushing Your Procurements
The internal decision-making process for the selection and approval of priority projects, including stimulus funded projects, remains subject to due diligence standards. While procurement operations should continue during the pandemic crisis, they need to be executed with both speed and precision.
For example, in a March 2019 report entitled Inquiry into procurement of work by Westland District Council at Franz Josef, New Zealand’s Auditor-General found significant flaws in the direct intervention by two local elected officials in a rushed municipal construction project that was initiated to protect a local wastewater facility from potential flooding. Those flaws included poor decision-making and procurement planning, questionable authorizations, and the absence of proper technical advice.
Similarly, in its 2010 report, the Ontario Auditor General found significant flaws in how the provincial government approved the funding for its $4 billion stimulus spending initiative. The Auditor General determined that the province failed to allocate adequate time and staff resources to the approval of thousands of municipal funding requests, that it failed to properly prioritize those requests, and that it failed to document the rationale behind its funding approval decisions to properly protect against the politicization of its spending decisions.
As these examples illustrate, a rush to market will be quickly replaced with a rush to judgment if due process standards are not followed, even when faced with urgent circumstances.
Procurement Business Continuity Recommendations
To help maintain procurement business continuity during the global pandemic, public institutions should consider the following guidelines:
- Do Not Overreact. While protecting employees and the public through social distancing may be a paramount consideration, public institutions should not overact by shutting down those business operations that can continue through remote working arrangements. Given the importance of public procurement to the overall economy, and the importance of the supply chain to ongoing government operations and public services, general procurement activities should continue with as limited disruption as possible. This will help avoid supply chain disruptions that impact public services while also minimizing the adverse economic impacts that would otherwise lead to layoffs across government and the private sector.
- Prioritize Genuine Emergencies. Ensure that critical goods and services that are essential to the health and safety of the public are made your top procurement priority and, where appropriate, rely on direct awards through emergency procurement protocols.
- Follow Proper Project Management Disciplines. Ensure that your procurements follow proper internal planning procedures and abide by open tendering protocols. A pandemic crisis does not give public institutions free licence to part company with due process and engage in panic buying.
Future Considerations
To serve the public interest, public sector decision-makers should prioritize their procurement planning since their procurement operations are critical to ensuring ongoing services to the public and minimizing adverse impacts to the broader economy.